Skip to main content

The Story of Hesiod and Pandora

 Pandora is the first woman of Greek mythology.  The Greek equivalent of Eve.  Eve has an apple, while Pandora has a box.  Both the apple and the box release misery onto the world of men.  Both Eve and Pandora are punished.  Like Eve, Pandora and all of her daughters are sentenced to "experience difficult childbirth.  Having demonstrated the untrustworthiness of her gender, she--and all women yet unborn--were to be dominated by their fathers and then by their husbands." (Quote source: Shlain).

I recently began reading Cassandra Speaks by Elizabeth Lesser, a book published in 2020, with the subtitle "When Women are the Storytellers, the Human Story Changes".  Part I of the book discusses origin stories.  Chapter 1 focuses on Eve, Chapter 2 focuses on Pandora.  The quote at the beginning of Pandora's chapter is from Polly Young-Eisendrath who writes,

"Both Eve and Pandora bring death into the world.  This is a curious reversal of the fact that women bring life into the world, but it says something about the meaning of 'woman' within a religion dominated by male gods."

Pandora's story comes to us from the poet Hesiod, who was writing at approximately the same time as Homer, author of Odyssey and the Iliad.  Lesser writes, "Historians refer to Hesiod's poems as the 'Genesis' of Greek mythology."  She goes on to say, "We relate to Hesiod's words as if they flowed directly from the mouths of the gods, but Hesiod interpreted old myths and folktales from the oral tradition, changing many of them to reflect the issues of his times and to protect the privilege of the ruling, patriarchal class."

Bust of Hesiod. 
By Yair Haklai - Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=93437400

I have also been rereading Leonard Shlain's remarkable bestseller from 1998, The Alphabet Versus the Goddess:  the Conflict Between Word and Image.  I first read it around Y2K and it was one of the first books that really expanded my worldview regarding religion.  Leonard Shlain was a brain surgeon who liked to travel.  In 1991 he was part of a tour of Mediterranean archeological sites guided by a University of Athens professor.  He writes, "At nearly every Greek site we visited, she patiently explained that the shrines we stood before had originally been consecrated to a female deity.  And, later, for unknown reasons, unknown persons reconsecrated them to a male one."  The tour encompassed Greece, Crete, and Ephesus on the Anatolian coast.   On the bus back to the airport he "was struck by the thought that the demise of the Goddess, the plunge in women's status, and the advent of harsh patriarchy and misogyny occurred around the time that people were learning how to read and write.  Perhaps there was something in the way people acquired this new skill that changed the brain's actual structure.  We know that in the developing brain of a child, differing kinds of learning will strengthen some neuronal pathways and weaken others.  Extrapolating the experience of an individual to a culture, [he] hypothesized that when a critical mass of people with a society acquire literacy, especially alphabetic literacy, left hemispheric modes of thought are reinforced at the expense of right hemispheric ones, which manifests as a decline in the status of images, women's rights, and goddess worship.  He spent the next seven years researching, exploring his idea, and writing the book.

About Hesiod's version of the myth of Pandora's box, Shlain writes "Pandora disobeyed the order not to open the box because she desired knowledge.  Her crime and punishment mirror Eve's in Eden.   Both stories have the same purpose:  to denigrate women, demote the Great Mother, and create a myth that enables men to dominate women.  Women must have possessed power prior to the creation of these stories, or it would not have been necessary for mythmakers to try to alter cultural perceptions."

Indeed, in Cassandra Speaks, Lesser writes, "In versions that predate Hesiod's storytelling, Pandora was not a punishment at all but rather a gift.  In fact, the name Pandora means 'all-giving.'  Earlier versions of the spoken myth, pieced together from the artwork on 5th century BCE pottery, paint Pandora as an embodiment of the fertility of the earth, a healer and a life giver."

Happily, even Wikipedia seems to be aware of this, today in 2023.  The brilliant Jane Ellen Harrision is even referenced in Pandora's Wikipedia article (she is probably also the source the Elizabeth Lesser refers to in Cassandra Speaks).  From Wikipedia:

"Jane Ellen Harrison[24] also turned to the repertory of vase-painters to shed light on aspects of myth that were left unaddressed or disguised in literature. On a fifth-century amphora in the Ashmolean Museum (her fig.71) the half-figure of Pandora emerges from the ground, her arms upraised in the epiphany gesture, to greet Epimetheus. A winged ker with a fillet hovers overhead: "Pandora rises from the earth; she is the Earth, giver of all gifts," Harrison observes. Over time this "all-giving" goddess somehow devolved into an "all-gifted" mortal woman. A.H. Smith,[25] however, noted that in Hesiod's account Athena and the Seasons brought wreaths of grass and spring flowers to Pandora, indicating that Hesiod was conscious of Pandora's original "all-giving" function. For Harrison, therefore, Hesiod's story provides "evidence of a shift from matriarchy to patriarchy in Greek culture. As the life-bringing goddess Pandora is eclipsed, the death-bringing human Pandora arises."[26] Thus, Harrison concludes "in the patriarchal mythology of Hesiod her great figure is strangely changed and diminished. She is no longer Earth-Born, but the creature, the handiwork of Olympian Zeus." (Harrison 1922:284). Robert Graves, quoting Harrison,[27] asserts of the Hesiodic episode that "Pandora is not a genuine myth, but an anti-feminist fable, probably of his own invention."

Thus was inspired my most recent painting, entitled "The Story of Hesiod and Pandora".  The story: 

Once upon a time there was an angry misogynistic man. He heard a story about the beautiful creator Goddess who brought all the good things to the world. She was the earth mother. Her name was Pandora, the giver of all things. Her festivals were joyous. This made the man jealous. But he felt powerful, because while the women had music and stories and beauty and the power to create life, he knew the alphabet and was wealthy. He inscribed on lead tablets the story of Pandora, the evil woman who brought all the bad things to the world. He felt better for a moment, but remained bitter to the end of his days. This man's words survived and were cherished by other bitter men for thousands of years. But eventually, his words were questioned and the truth of the Goddess was brought forth again. And She lived happily ever after.

The painting:


The Story of Pandora and Hesiod
The Story of Pandora and Hesiod, original painting by Echoing Multiverse, available via Saatchi Art.  Prints, stickers, and other merch available through RedBubble or Fine Art America.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Demeter, Fertility, and the Sacred Pig

 Demeter and her daughter Persephone were honored every spring and fall at the Eleusinian Mysteries, held in Eleusis, a town near Athens.  According to a 2018 exhibit in the Acropolis Museum, reported here , "Every prospective pilgrim had to sacrifice a piglet in honor of Demeter."  It is likely that the piglets were sacrificed on "the second day of the celebration, since the pilgrims returned from the sea where they themselves and the sacrificed animals had a purifying bath." According to the exhibit catalogue, "piglet sacrifice in honor of the goddess Demeter was a common practice in the whole ancient world, both in ancient Greece and in the colonies." I've been pondering pigs lately, specifically in relation to the Goddess.  Are the Jewish and Muslim pork bans related to Goddess worship?  Insert shrug emoji here. In an article from the University of Michigan Museum of Art and Archaeology, about a bronze coin from Eleusis, the author writes, "T...

Eve of the Apocalypse, Protungulatum donnae

 Protungulatum donnae is the Eve of placental mammals.  The first mammal to give birth to live young.  She is "the lovely lady squirrel from whence all extant, placenta-having, non-marsupial mammals evolved." Our great-grand rat.  A very early ancestor Goddess.  She appears in the fossil record right about the time of the giant asteroid impact apocalypse and following apocalyptic winter that wiped out the dinosaurs.  She ate beetles and didn't have to worry about keeping her eggs warm.  She was small, about squirrel sized.  The mutations that led to live birth apparently gave her a post apocalyptic advantage, as her DNA lives on.     Eve of the Apocalypse. Protungulatum donnae, in her burrow, resting after live birth. (Not to scale).  Original painting by Echoing Multiverse available via Saatchi Art .  Stickers and other merch available via RedBubble or Fine Art America .   Inspired by Eve: How the Female Body D...

Dewi Danu

 Dewi Danu is a Balinese water, lake and river Goddess.  The form of Hinduism practiced in Bali is also called Agama Tirta, or religion of the water ( source ).  The "floating temple" of Pura Ulun Danu Bratan, on the western shore of Lake Bratan, is dedicated to Dewi Danu ( source ).  Built in 1633, the temple is used for offerings and ceremonies dedicated to the Goddess, due to the importance of Lake Bratan as a main source of irrigation in central Bali ( source ). In Bali, besides supporting irrigated agriculture, holy water also holds power that can "cleanse spiritual impurities, fend off evil forces, and render the recipient immune to the attacks of negative or demonic forces."  "In Indonesian Hindu Dharma, the 4 elements of Nature, or panchamahabhuta (Earth, Water, Fire, Air) are used in all religious rituals. Out of those, Water is the building block of life and of all living beings that are at the mercy of [the] God[dess]" ( source ). Dewi Danu orig...

The Cycle of Venus

Learning about goddesses has led me to learn a bit about astronomy.  Many goddesses and a few gods throughout history have been associated with the morning star and the evening star .  Different cultures discovered at different times that both of these stars are the same celestial object, known today as the planet Venus - the third brightest object in the sky after the Sun and the moon.  The internet contains diagrams of the cycle of Venus, but I couldn't find one that put all of the pieces together.  So I drew one!  Here, I use a symbol from reliefs of Inanna to represent Venus's current position in her cycle. She just transited behind the Sun (represented by the Norse goddess Sol), and has reappeared low on the horizon as the evening star, which she will embody for the rest of 2021 before vanishing for 8 days to reappear as the morning star for most of 2022 ( source ). The Cycle of Venus, as viewed from Earth, not to scale The disappearance and reappearanc...

Nuwa

Nuwa is the great mother goddess of Chinese mythology, credited with creating humanity. She molded the first people out of clay by hand. Then she got tired, dipped a rope in the mud, and swung it around her head to make more. Thus were made the nobles and the peasantry. She has the body of a serpent. Nuwa, original painting by Echoing Multiverse.  Available via Saatchi Art .

Chang e, Moon Goddess

Chang e or Chang o, the Chinese moon goddess. The details of her story vary, but generally she is married to an archer who shoots 9 of the 10 suns to prevent the Earth from scorching drought.  He is awarded elixir of immortality by the Great Queen Mother Goddess of the West.  To keep the elixir from burglars, Chang e drinks it.  The elixir causes her to float up to the moon, where she is separated from her husband, but at least has a jade rabbit and busy woodcutter for company. China's lunar landers are named after her. Chang E, Moon Goddess original painting by Echoing Multiverse available via Saatchi Art .  Stickers, prints, and other merch available through RedBubble or Fine Art America . In older stories, she also births the 12 moons.  In some versions of the story with the archer, Chang e is reunited with him during the 8th moon of each year.  The Mid-Autumn Festival celebrates this reunion, and is one of the largest holidays in China.  According...